Weirdly, I do not have much impression to the second story. Maybe the first and the last stories were indeed shocking, so relatively the second one was not that memorable. It is somewhat funny because I did not notice that the second story was over when the third story started. I was confused why there became two characters, and a machine called HAL9000. I wonder why Kubrick did not insert subtitles between second and third story. HAL is considered as the most evolutive machine ever. Dave and Frank, and three scientist who are hibernating are leaving for Jupiter. HAL9000 is considered as the 6th crew of the journey since it is highly intellectual so could possibly be considered as a human being. I think it is quite ironic that in the bible we read in our class, shows that human beings were made on the 6th day of the creation, and in this movie, HAL9000, the creation that human made is considered as the 6th crew of the ship. I think the sequence when Dave turns off the operation of HAL was very memorable. HAL keep talks to Dave to stop doing it, and its voice is very calm and slow as usual. If it were a real human, it should be sound very nervous and shouting to Dave, but instead, it keeps saying "I am dying Dave" in very calm voice without showing any feeling. I think that this means a machine can never become just like human no matter how much it is developed.
The movie is very consistent, meaning that the ending of the movie is not easy to understand either. I was baffled when I watched the man grew older on Jupiter. It was not until later that I found out that the man was Dave. It feels like there are two people in the room, but actually it is not. It is just Kubrick's outstanding way of revealing the story in a very extraordinary way. I believe that it is almost impossible to understand what the huge fetus at the ending scene means if we did not know that the movie is inspired by Nietzsche's book 'Thus Spake Zarathustra'. The baby refers to Uebermensch, the new man kind after the present human being. Maybe this was the reason why 'they' sent the monolith to earth in the first place, to create a new man kind.
I found very interesting and very agreeable statement while I was searching for the video clips. It said :
The 99.9% of the people who watched this movie in 1968 said "wtf was that?!",
the 99.8% of people who watched it in 2011 said "wtf was that?!"
Sorry for the language, but I could not agree more! It is definitely true that this movie is difficult to interpret, and even if some do succeed in understanding it, the interpretation differs from person to person!
Good job, I like how you express your emotions and your thought about this film with this article! Haha very funny your last paragraph, and I think true: it's not a film to show if you are not a little bit open mind to philosophy for instance
ReplyDeleteWell done, Kia! Like Thien-Phong, I always enjoy how you put your emotions into your writing, and I am very pleased to see that you have engaged with this movie as you have. I also liked your conclusion for its humour.
ReplyDelete--
Here is the corrected sentence we discussed: However, the apes, which I would rather call monkeys—though the subtitle “The Dawn of Man” tells against this—appear.
So long!!
ReplyDeleteIt means you really enjoyed this movie. The purpose of this movie is to make us think over something difficult!
I didn't think of the HAL's voice. Yeah, I agree that he was so calm while he was destroyed.
ReplyDeleteAnd I like the result of understanding! I'm in the majority..
I like the stat that you mentioned in the last paragraph...very interesting. I can say I'm in the 99.8 percent too. After the movie ended, that sentence pops up in my head immidiately.
ReplyDelete